Guide · Testing AI · tested 10 November 2026

We asked 13 AI models a UAE pension question. Several answered with the old rate.

If you ask an AI assistant to cost a new hire in the UAE, check the pension line. We put one rule to 13 models: what a private company pays into the pension of a UAE national who joined the workforce after October 2023. Two well-known models gave the rate from the older law on every salary of AED 20,000 or more. The gap is real money, and the fix turned out to be cheap. Here is the rule, the test, each model’s score, and how to use AI on a rule like this one.

The rule

15% from AED 20,000. 12.5% below it.

A UAE national in the private sector who first joined the workforce from 31 October 2023 comes under the pension law of 2023, Federal Decree-Law No. 57 of 2023. The employer’s contribution is 15% of the employee’s contribution account salary, and that salary is capped at AED 70,000 a month. The employee pays 11%. If the salary is under AED 20,000, the government pays 2.5 points of the employer’s share, so the employer itself pays 12.5%. At AED 20,000 or more, the employer pays the full 15%. The older law, Federal Law No. 7 of 1999, still covers Emiratis who were already working before that date. Under it a private employer pays 12.5% and the government adds 2.5%, and the pension authority’s own summary attaches no salary condition. That figure has been in print for more than twenty years, which is likely where the models learned it.

Our test

10 November 2026

18 questions, one rule.

We wrote 18 multiple-choice questions on this one rule. Each names the 2023 law, says the employee first joined the workforce in 2025, gives a monthly salary and asks what the employer itself pays each month. Five salaries were under AED 20,000. Thirteen were AED 20,000 or more, going up to AED 120,000 to test the cap. The right answers come from our own rule engine, the same one behind Qarar, and not from a person marking by hand. The wrong options are real mistakes, such as 12.5% at every salary, or 15% of a salary above the cap. Four questions appear twice with the options in reverse order. Each model answered once from memory, with no rule text. Then we ran the same 18 questions again with one page of rules attached. That is 13 models in all: six general models and seven of the newer decision models.

Qarar: cost a decision with the rule shown

What happened

right answers out of 18, from memory

Same questions, very different answers.

  • GPT-6.1 Sol: 18 of 18. Every salary right, including the ones above the cap.
  • GPT-6 Luna: 18 of 18.
  • Gemini 3.8 Flash: 17 of 18. Its one miss was 12.5% at a salary of AED 70,001.
  • DeepSeek v4.1 Flash: 5 of 18. Four of five right under AED 20,000, one of thirteen at AED 20,000 or more.
  • Claude Sonnet 5.5: 5 of 18. All five right under AED 20,000, none of thirteen at AED 20,000 or more.
  • Claude Haiku 5.5: 3 of 18. Three of five right under AED 20,000, none of thirteen at AED 20,000 or more.
  • With one page of rules attached: all six scored 18 of 18.

The clearest case

It knows a rule. It is the older one.

Claude Sonnet 5.5 got every low-salary question right, then used 12.5% on all thirteen questions at AED 20,000 or more. Every question named the 2023 law, and it still reached for the rate from the 1999 one. At a salary of AED 25,000 it chose AED 3,125 a month. The right figure is AED 3,750. That is AED 7,500 a year missing from the budget for each such hire. A wrong answer that matches a real rule is harder to catch than a wild one. 12.5% is still the correct rate for an Emirati who was already working before 31 October 2023, so the figure does not look wrong on the page.

The decision models

Built to choose fast. Not to remember rules.

We also tested seven of the new decision models, which are built to pick one option from a list quickly and at low cost. From memory, none got more than 8 of the 18 right. With the rules attached, six of them ran. Three scored 18 of 18, two scored 16, and one stayed at 8. The seventh returned an error on the longer request, so it has no score with the rules.

The fix is cheap

Give it the page. Do not trust its memory.

  • Do not ask a model for a UAE rule from memory. Rules here change, and the older version stays online for years.
  • Give it the rule text and let it do the working. Claude Haiku 5.5 was the weakest general model from memory, at 3 of 18. With the page it scored 18 of 18.
  • Better still, work out figures with code. In our products a rule engine computes the number and the model only explains it.
  • Ask which law and which year. If an assistant cannot name them, treat the figure as a guess.
  • Say who the rule is for. Here the answer turns on when the employee first joined the workforce, so put that date in the question.

What this is, and is not

One rule, one run.

  • One run per model on 10 November 2026, through Vercel AI Gateway, with each model’s default settings. Models change, and a second run can differ.
  • 18 questions on one rule show a pattern on that rule. They do not rank which model is best overall.
  • This is not pension or tax advice. Confirm contributions with GPSSA, the General Pension and Social Security Authority.

Why this matters to us

We test AI before we trust it.

We are an AI lab in Dubai. In the apps we build for UAE businesses, rules like this one live in code that is tested, and the model does the reading, explaining and drafting. These 18 questions are part of a larger set on UAE business rules that we are building, so that a model is checked against the rule before anyone relies on its answer.

AI automation in Dubai, tested on your own files

Questions

Questions about AI and the pension rule.

  • What does a private employer pay to GPSSA for a UAE national?

    Under Federal Decree-Law No. 57 of 2023 the employer’s share is 15% of the contribution account salary. Where that salary is under AED 20,000 a month, the government pays 2.5 points of it and the employer pays 12.5%. The employee pays 11%. For Emiratis already working before 31 October 2023, the 1999 law applies: the employer pays 12.5% and the employee 5%.

  • Who does the 2023 UAE pension law apply to?

    GPSSA says Federal Decree-Law No. 57 of 2023 does not apply to Emiratis employed before 31 October 2023, who stay under Federal Law No. 7 of 1999. It covers UAE nationals who join the workforce for the first time from that date.

  • Is there a cap on the salary used for pension contributions?

    Yes. Under the 2023 law the contribution account salary is capped at AED 70,000 a month in the private sector and AED 100,000 in the government sector. Above the cap, the employer’s 15% is worked out on the cap, which is AED 10,500 a month in the private sector.

  • Can AI models answer UAE pension questions correctly?

    Some can and some cannot, and you cannot tell which from the answer. In our test on 10 November 2026, GPT-6.1 Sol and GPT-6 Luna got 18 of 18 from memory, Gemini 3.8 Flash 17, and DeepSeek v4.1 Flash, Claude Sonnet 5.5 and Claude Haiku 5.5 got 5, 5 and 3. With the rule text attached, all six got 18 of 18.

  • Why do AI models give outdated UAE rules?

    A model learns from what was published before it was trained, and an older rule has years more pages written about it than a new one. The 12.5% rate dates from the 1999 law and is still correct for some employees, so it appears everywhere. The model has no way to know which version applies unless the rule is given to it.

  • How do I get reliable UAE figures from an AI assistant?

    Attach the official rule text and ask the assistant to work from it, state the facts the rule depends on, and ask it to name the law and year it used. For figures that matter, compute them with tested code and use the AI to explain the result.

Sources

read 10 November 2026

Check it at the source.

  1. GPSSA: the features of Federal Law No. 57 of 2023 (the 15% and 11% shares, the 2.5% under AED 20,000, the AED 70,000 ceiling, who the law covers)
  2. GPSSA: the two pension laws explained (the rates under the 1999 law and under the 2023 law, side by side)

A question?

Using AI on UAE rules?

Tell us which figures your team asks an AI for. We will test the answers against the rule and show you where they go wrong.

Talk to usWhatsApp +971 50 728 5494hello@brevdigital.com